After a few days of thinking about it, I concur with Caleb. If liberalism means that we root our intellectual heritage in Locke and Milton, I am out. If anti-liberalism roots us in Hooker, Burke, John Randolph of Roanoke, and R.L. Dabney, I am an anti-liberal.
But I am not a monarchist. I am a Republican. I believe in maximizing human liberty to the fullest extent compatible with biblical morality. Does this make a liberal conservative?